Return to Geri Ashley's HomePage

Return to Language Arts Page

Go to Practicing Reading

Children's Storybooks Online

 

Practice Reading Comprehension Passages--> Mrs. Nussbaum's Reading Comprehension Passages

 

Contrasting Good and Poor Readers - READING IS THINKING!!!!!
 
Good Readers
Poor Readers
Before Reading: 
  1. "Activate" their background knowledge on the subject.
  2. Question and wonder.
  3. Know their purpose for reading.
  4. Look for the structure of the piece of reading.
  5. Believe they are in control of the reading process
Before Reading: 
  1. Start reading without thinking about the subject.
  2. Do not know why they are reading -- except that it is an assignment.
During Reading: 
  1. Give their complete attention to the reading task.
  2. Make Text-to-Self, Text-to-Text, and Text-to-World Connections.
  3. Keep a constant check on their comprehension of the reading material.
  4. Stop to use a "figure-it-out" strategy when they do not understand what they read.
  5. Know that they can make sense of it eventually with use of strategies.
  6. Look for important ideas and see how details relate to the whole.
  7. Visualize, "Go to the movies in their head."
  8. Make inferences using their schema and text information
  9. Accept the challenge of being frustrated or confused and deal with it.
  10. Realize that the problem may be the way the author wrote rather than the reader's inability to understand.
During Reading: 
  1. Do not know whether they understand or do not understand.
  2. Do not monitor their own comprehension.
  3. Seldom use any "figure-it-out" strategies.
  4. View reading as looking at words and turning pages -- the quicker the better.
  5. Are sometimes adept at phonic analysis but do not go for meaning. (They can say the words but don't know what they mean.)
  6. Can be bored by the process of reading.
After Reading: 
  1. Decide if they achieved their goal for making meaning from reading.
  2. Evaluate their comprehension.
  3. Summarize what they read.
  4. Seek additional information if curious to know more.
  5. Think through the information and decide whether it was useful or not.
After Reading: 
  1. Do not know what they have read.
  2. Do not follow reading with comprehension self-check.
  3. See no connections between what they read and anything else.

 

STRATEGIES THAT GREAT READERS USE

 

Activating and Using Background Knowledge

This strategy requires readers to activate their background knowledge and to use that knowledge to help them understand what they are reading. Background knowledge is made up of a person's experiences with the world (including what he or she has read), along with his or her concepts for how written text works, including word identification, print concepts, word meaning, and how text is organized. Research has established that readers' existing knowledge is critical in determining their ability to comprehend what they read.2

One of the most important contributions made by cognitive scientists to the understanding of how comprehension works is schema theory.[3] This theory is based on how people organize and activate their knowledge.

According to schema theory, as people learn about the world, they develop a large network of knowledge structures, or schemas, with each schema connected to many others. These schemas grow and change as a person acquires new information through experience and reading. For example, a very young child's schema for dog might contain only her or his understanding of the family pet something white, furry, and fun to play with. As the child gains more experiences with a variety of dogs in a variety of settings, the dog schema will expand and be refined. It may connect to other schema types of dogs; colors of dogs; foods dogs eat; places where dogs stay when the family is on vacation; dangerous dogs; who veterinarians are; and locations of important dog shows.

When they applied schema theory to reading comprehension, cognitive scientists found that good readers constantly connect their background knowledge to the new knowledge they encounter in a text. In fact, they appear to activate a schema as soon they begin to read. The initial schema then activates others, thus directly affecting how readers understand and react to a text.4

Schemas that are related to text organization are especially important to comprehension. Having knowledge of a text's organization improves students' understanding of that text.

Generating and Asking Questions

This strategy involves readers asking themselves questions throughout the reading of a text. The ability of readers to ask themselves relevant questions as they read is especially valuable in helping them to integrate information, identify main ideas, and summarize information. Asking the right questions allows good readers to focus on the most important information in a text.6

Generating good questions may also lead readers to focus on problems with comprehension and to take actions to deal with these problems.

   

Making Inferences

This strategy requires readers to evaluate or draw conclusions from information in a text. Authors do not always provide complete descriptions of, or explicit information about a topic, setting, character, or event. However, they often provide clues that readers can use to "read between the lines"-by making inferences that combine information in the text with their background knowledge.

It has been shown that when readers are taught how to make inferences, they improve their abilities to construct meaning. Indeed, research indicates that the ability to make inferences is crucial to successful reading.

Predicting

This strategy involves the ability of readers to get meaning from a text by making informed predictions. Good readers use predicting as a way to connect their existing knowledge to new information from a text to get meaning from what they read.9 Before reading, they may use what they know about an author to predict what a text will be about. The title of a text may trigger memories of texts with similar content, allowing them to predict the content of the new text.

During reading, good readers may make predictions about what is going to happen next, or what ideas or evidence the author will present to support an argument. They tend to evaluate these predictions continuously, and revise any prediction that is not confirmed by the reading.

   

Summarizing

This strategy involves the ability of readers to pull together, or synthesize information in a text so as to explain in their own words what the text is about. Summarizing is an important strategy because it can enable readers to recall text quickly. It also can make readers more aware of text organization, of what is important in a text and of how ideas are related.10

Effective summarizing of expository text may involve such things as condensing the steps in a scientific process, the stages of development of an art movement, or the episodes that led to some major historical event.

Effective summarizing of narrative text can involve such things as connecting and synthesizing events in a story line or identifying the factors that motivate a character's actions and behavior.

Visualizing

This involves the ability of readers to make mental images of a text as a way to understand processes or events they encounter during reading. This ability can be an indication that a reader understands a text. Some research suggests that readers who visualize as they read are better able to recall what they have read than are those who do not visualize.11

Visualizing is especially valuable when it is applied to narrative texts. In reading narratives, readers often can develop a clear understanding of what is happening by visualizing the setting, characters, or actions in the plot. However, visualizing can also be applied to the reading of expository texts, with readers visualizing steps in a process or stages in an event or creating an image to help them remember some abstract concept or important name.

   

Comprehension Monitoring

This involves the ability of readers to know when they understand what they read, when they do not understand, and to use appropriate strategies to improve their understanding when it is blocked. Comprehension monitoring is a form of metacognition. Good readers are aware of and monitor their thought processes as they read. In contrast, poor readers "just do it."

The strategies employed by good readers to improve understanding are called "repair" or "fix-up" strategies. Specific repair strategies include rereading, reading ahead, clarifying words by looking them up in a dictionary or glossary, or asking someone for help.

In general, good readers use a variety of strategies such as the ones just discussed to construct meaning as they read. However, not all good readers use the same strategies; good readers tend to develop and practice those strategies that are most useful to them. Further, good readers are flexible in their strategy use: they switch from strategy to strategy as they read; they use different strategies with different kinds of texts.

 
   
   

 

Preview the text

To preview any course material, take a moment before reading to do the following:

Previewing is an important step because course material can often deal with unfamiliar subject matter about which you have little or no background knowledge. Previewing is useful because it helps you make decisions about how to approach the material. Previewing gets your mind "in gear," gives you a mental outline of the topic, and alerts you to what you already know.

(Adapted with permission from Study and Thinking Skills in College, by Kathleen T. McWhorter, 1988).


Establish your purpose for reading.

Why are you reading course texts or recommended websites? Your purpose for reading affects how you approach the material. Are you reading:

Once you know why you are reading, you are more likely to know when you have accomplished your reading goal. When you have accomplished that goal, you should stop reading.

For overall concepts, you may only need to read headings and introductory and summary paragraphs and look at diagrams.

If you are reading to learn the parts and functions of a complex system, like the circulatory system in the body, you will need to read and review the material several times. You may even need to sketch and label parts of the system in order to know it well enough to be able to use that information.

Pace yourself for your purpose.

When previewing a chapter, website, or other text, skim quickly over headings, diagrams, illustrations, and highlighted text. You can read rapidly if you are reading to learn important ideas or overall concepts. Be prepared to read detailed information more slowly. You may have to reread diagrams, graphs, or descriptions of procedures several times. If you are reading unfamiliar topics, you should skim over the material once to get a mental outline of the topic and then read it again carefully so you will gain a better understanding of the material.

Identify what you already know.

You learn more easily if you can connect new information to what you already know. Search your previous experience and knowledge for ideas to connect to the new material. You will find you are more likely to remember new information that is connected to what you already know. This step can also draw your attention to gaps in what you already know or mismatches between new information and your existing understanding. Those gaps or mismatches are an opportunity to ask questions. If you are not sure that the connection you've made between new and previous knowledge is sound, check your thinking with your instructor.

Paraphrase in your own words.

If you can express the author's ideas in your own words, you understand them. If you find yourself using only the author's words, then you need to do more work to integrate those ideas into your own understanding. Read the text carefully and focus on the ideas and relationships between ideas rather than the words used to express them.

Use the graphics in your text.

Graphics such as drawings, tables, charts, or diagrams in academic or technical material usually contain important information. Refer frequently to graphics when reading text that discusses or explains the information that they are representing. Take time to connect the written explanation to the specific parts of the graphic.

Visualize while you read.

Create mental images of the process, procedure, or topic described in the text. Imagine yourself performing the procedure and focus on the details or steps throughout. Imagining a written description can improve your memory, especially if you prefer to learn about a procedure by seeing a demonstration of it rather than reading about it.

Apply what you're learning.

As you read, take time to think of examples that illustrate the idea in the text. Apply the concept to situations you are familiar with, such as your own work context. Think about how you would explain the idea to someone else and ways you would link the idea to knowledge they already have. Draw a picture to represent the idea and how you understand it.